Personality assessment
Personality assessment for hiring: how to choose a test for recruitment
Compare personality assessments for recruitment, understand their predictive value and learn what evidence to request from providers.

How this article was written
This article draws on published research and professional practice across psychology, psychometrics, behavioural science, people analytics, AI and learning sciences. All evidence and conclusions are reviewed by the author, with references provided for further reading. AI may assist with research and editing.
Overview
Personality assessments can help employers understand how candidates tend to think, behave and approach their work. But how useful are these assessments for predicting job performance? And how much influence should a personality score have on a hiring decision? These questions matter because personality tests vary in what they measure, how candidates respond and how their results are interpreted.
A questionnaire may provide useful information about someone without offering sufficient evidence to predict how they will perform in a particular role. This article examines research on personality and job performance, compares four providers' published assessment approaches and discusses evidence for using scores in recruitment.
The research reviewed here examines personality scores, applicant responses and recruitment outcomes. Provider websites describe the available assessments and their intended uses. Our observations draw on these sources and our professional judgement. The Inner View also provides personality assessment services, so we distinguish professional judgement from independently established findings.
What does a personality assessment measure?
Personality refers to relatively stable patterns in how people tend to think, feel and behave. These patterns can influence how someone approaches responsibilities, interacts with colleagues and responds to different situations. Personality questionnaires attempt to measure these characteristics systematically, usually by asking people to describe themselves through a series of statements or questions.
For example, conscientiousness concerns tendencies such as being organised, preparing for tasks, pursuing goals and following through on responsibilities. Someone with a higher conscientiousness score may be more likely to describe themselves as organised and dependable. However, a score represents an estimate of a personality characteristic. It does not establish how someone will behave in every situation or whether they can perform a particular job.
Personality assessments also differ in how they describe individual differences.
- Trait-based assessments measure characteristics along continuous dimensions. Someone might score higher or lower on conscientiousness, for example, rather than belonging to a fixed personality category.
- Type-based assessments place people into categories based on their reported preferences or characteristics.
This distinction matters in recruitment because an assessment designed to describe psychological type may not be appropriate for predicting job performance. The Myers-Briggs Company, for example, states that assessments of psychological type are not designed for hiring or selection decisions. [1] [2]
The company describes trait-based assessments as generally appropriate for selection. [2] Even then, we encourage employers to establish the relevance of a particular trait in relation to the job. Conscientiousness may be useful to examine for a role requiring careful organisation and follow-through. It may help to ask whether the questionnaire provides evidence that its scores support the intended decisions.
Can personality tests predict job performance?
Research has consistently examined whether personality characteristics are associated with how people perform at work. One widely studied trait is conscientiousness.
A meta-analysis by Watrin and colleagues investigated the relationship between self-reported conscientiousness and supervisor-rated job performance. A meta-analysis combines findings from multiple studies to estimate the overall relationship between variables. [3] The researchers examined 102 correlations from studies involving job applicants and people already employed.
A correlation describes the direction and strength of a relationship between two measured characteristics. Positive correlations indicate that higher values on one measure tend to occur alongside higher values on another.
Across the studies reviewed, the average correlation between conscientiousness and supervisor-rated performance was r = .17. [3] This represents a modest positive relationship. People reporting higher conscientiousness tended to receive somewhat higher performance ratings from supervisors, although the association was far from strong.
Squaring the correlation gives approximately 3%, meaning that conscientiousness scores account for about 3% of the variation in supervisor-rated job performance in a simple statistical model. This illustrates a modest relationship, but does not mean that personality causes 3% of job performance. The findings also become more complicated when we distinguish between employees and applicants.
Why applicant evidence matters
Most studies in the review involved people who were already employed, often measuring personality and job performance around the same time.
However, employers selecting new candidates face a different question: can a questionnaire completed during recruitment help predict how someone will perform after being hired? The evidence directly addressing this question was limited.
The review also excluded forced-choice questionnaires, which require people to choose between alternative descriptions. Its findings therefore should not automatically be generalised to that response format. [3] The researchers concluded that the available evidence was insufficient to answer confidently how well self-reported conscientiousness predicts subsequent job performance among actual applicants.
Will the questionnaire be as informative about someone applying for a job, when most research concerns people already employed? A relationship within an existing workforce does not necessarily establish predictive value during recruitment.
The modest average relationship also leaves considerable uncertainty when interpreting an individual candidate's score. A higher conscientiousness score does not establish that one candidate will outperform another.
How applicants respond to personality questions
Another consideration is whether people answer differently when they know an assessment may influence their employment prospects. Applicants may present themselves more favourably, particularly when questionnaire statements describe characteristics that employers are likely to value. This form of self-presentation can affect the meaning of personality scores and complicate comparisons between candidates.
Wood and colleagues examined this issue in a 2024 study involving 584 psychology undergraduates at an Australian university. Participants completed personality questionnaires under ordinary conditions and again approximately four weeks later in a simulated job application setting. [4]
The researchers compared a standard personality questionnaire with a modified version containing less evaluative wording. The aim was to investigate whether making statements sound less clearly positive or negative would reduce favourable responding. For example, the statement "I often feel blue" was changed to "I sometimes feel flat". [4]
The results showed that participants described themselves more favourably in the job application simulation. However, changing the wording did not consistently reduce this effect. Whether the modified questionnaire showed an advantage depended on how favourable responding was measured. [4]
The researchers also examined how the five broad personality traits, considered together, related to several outcomes. The average relationship was smaller in the simulated application setting for both questionnaires, and the two versions showed similar relationships in that setting. [4] Importantly, the outcomes included self-reported university grades and exercise frequency, rather than actual workplace performance. The study also involved students in a simulated recruitment situation, so its findings should not be treated as direct evidence about real job applicants.
Nevertheless, it highlights a relevant measurement problem: changing how personality questions are written does not necessarily prevent applicants from presenting themselves favourably. Questions for providers therefore include how their assessments have been studied in recruitment settings and whether applicant responding affects score interpretation or prediction. You can also ask us about these questions.
What personality assessment providers offer
Personality assessment providers differ in the characteristics they measure, their questionnaire formats and the purposes for which they recommend their products. Some offer broad personality profiles, while others focus on working preferences or characteristics considered relevant to employment.
For example, Talogy describes its 16pf (Sixteen Personality Factor) Questionnaire as measuring 16 primary personality factors and five global factors. The SHL Occupational Personality Questionnaire (OPQ) examines working preferences to support hiring and development, according to its product page. [5] [6]
Criteria offers employment personality tests alongside other recruitment tools, including cognitive aptitude and skills assessments. Its page distinguishes behavioural tendencies from capabilities relevant to performing work. [7]
The Myers-Briggs Company takes a different position on selection, explicitly stating that its psychological type assessment should not be used to make hiring decisions. [2] These descriptions indicate how providers position their products. They do not independently establish how accurately any particular assessment predicts performance in your organisation.
| Provider and assessmenta | What it measures | Completion time | Stated use or requirements |
|---|---|---|---|
| Talogy, 16pf | Personality measures include 16 primary factors and five global factors. | Approximately 30 to 40 minutes | Selection and development. Accreditation required. |
| SHL, OPQ | Working preferences and occupational personality characteristics. | Approximately 20 minutes | Hiring and development planning. User requirements not stated on the reviewed page.b |
| Criteria, personality assessment examples | Employee Personality Profile: 12 traits. Criteria Personality Inventory: Big Five traits. | Approximately 10 minutes per assessment | Pre-employment assessment. User requirements not stated on the reviewed page.b |
| The Myers-Briggs Company, MBTI | Psychological type and individual preferences. | Not stated on the reviewed page.b | The provider does not support its use for hiring or selection. User requirements not stated on the reviewed page.b |
aThe table reflects provider descriptions retrieved on 16 November 2026, without independently assessing the products. All product names belong to their respective owners.
b"Not stated" means the information was not available on the particular page reviewed.
The four providers' descriptive pages reviewed on 16 November 2026 did not give specific reliability or validity statistics. This review did not cover their separate research sections. [1] [2] [5] [6] [7]
This does not mean supporting research is unavailable. Descriptive pages outline products, while technical documentation addresses measurement evidence. Employers may wish to request the relevant technical documentation, including evidence for the specific questionnaire version, candidate population and intended use.
The sources reviewed also do not provide an independent ranking of these assessments or establish how widely employers use them. Market presence and product availability describe different matters from predictive accuracy.
What does a validated personality test mean for your role?
Employers may wish to examine claims of scientific development or validation in relation to the purpose of the assessment. Two measurement concepts are particularly important: reliability and validity.
Reliability concerns the consistency and precision of assessment scores. For example, if someone completes the same personality questionnaire twice under comparable conditions, how stable are their scores? Repeated testing is one way to examine reliability, although other forms of evidence may also be relevant depending on the assessment.
Validity concerns whether evidence supports the interpretation and use of those scores for a particular purpose. In recruitment, the question is whether the evidence supports using a personality score to inform decisions about candidates' suitability or expected job performance. These two concepts are related, but they are not interchangeable.
A relationship within an existing workforce does not necessarily establish predictive value during recruitment.
A questionnaire might produce consistent conscientiousness scores without establishing that they predict performance in a particular customer-service, managerial or technical role. The Myers-Briggs Company similarly distinguishes between the technical quality of an assessment and evidence supporting its use in selection. It notes that evidence for one purpose may not justify using the instrument for another. [2]
For employers, it may help to ask two separate questions:
- How reliable are the scores? What evidence demonstrates their consistency and precision in the relevant population?
- How valid is the proposed interpretation? What research supports using those scores to predict the outcomes relevant to the job?
Where a provider claims predictive validity, we encourage employers to request studies that follow applicants into employment and examine their subsequent performance. It may help to examine how performance was measured, who participated, the strength of the relationships found and the uncertainty surrounding the estimates. Evidence from comparable jobs and candidate populations is particularly relevant. Findings from another occupation or country may still be informative, but we encourage employers to check their applicability.
The same principle applies when evaluating other psychological constructs. For example, an emotional intelligence assessment may measure self-reported characteristics or performance on ability-based tasks. These methods provide different forms of information and require evidence appropriate to their intended use.

Fairness and employer responsibility
Predicting job performance is only one consideration when evaluating personality assessments for recruitment. We also encourage employers to examine whether their assessment processes treat different candidate groups fairly and whether selection recommendations have unintended consequences.
A 2023 study by Kubiak and colleagues investigated recommendations generated by personality-based algorithms using existing data from the AssessFirst platform. The analysis involved platform users primarily from France, and three of the authors were employed by AssessFirst. [8] The researchers examined whether recommendation rates differed between women and men. This addresses a different question from predictive validity: who is recommended by the system, rather than whether those recommendations identify future job performance.
To investigate these differences, the researchers used an impact ratio. An impact ratio compares the selection or recommendation rates of two groups. It is calculated by dividing one group's rate by the other's. For example, imagine that 40% of women and 50% of men are recommended. Dividing 40% by 50% gives 0.80, so the first group's rate is four-fifths of the second's.
The researchers examined 208 models developed for 18 employers, using data from 273,293 platform users. [8] Eight of the 124 models evaluated using the female-to-male recommendation ratio fell below the study's 0.80 threshold. Of the 84 models evaluated using the reverse comparison, three fell below that threshold. [8] The remaining models met the threshold used in the analysis. However, meeting a particular statistical threshold does not, by itself, establish fairness across other groups or freedom from bias.
The study also had several limitations. It examined algorithmic recommendations rather than final hiring decisions, which remained with employers. The platform users were not necessarily applicants to the occupations studied, and the analysis considered women and men without examining other demographic groups. [8] Consequently, the findings cannot establish whether the recommendations improved recruitment outcomes, predicted job performance or produced comparable results across other candidate populations. These distinctions matter because fairness evidence needs to be interpreted in relation to what was measured, which groups were examined and how the assessment is used.
Guidance from regulators and professional bodies
Published guidance addresses both assessment evidence and the procedures surrounding its use. In the United States, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission provides guidance on employment tests and selection procedures. Its technical assistance, issued in 2007, advises employers to ensure that assessments are validated for the positions and purposes for which they are used. [9]
On supplier documentation, the EEOC states that the employer remains responsible for ensuring validity under the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (UGESP). The document itself states that it does not have the force and effect of law. [9]
GOV.UK describes restrictions on questions about protected characteristics during recruitment in Great Britain. [10] Its guidance limits health or disability questions to specified circumstances, including finding out whether someone needs help with a selection test or interview. [10]
The British Psychological Society (BPS) also emphasises the importance of appropriate testing policies, reasonable adjustments for candidates with disabilities and clear communication about assessment purposes. It states that test-takers should receive an explanation of what the questionnaire involves, why it is being used and what will happen with their results. [11]
These considerations extend beyond choosing a technically sound questionnaire. BPS guidance covers testing procedures, making reasonable adjustments and training those administering assessments. [11] A provider may supply the instrument and technical documentation, but we encourage employers to establish how the assessment fits into their recruitment process.
Choosing a personality assessment for recruitment
In our experience, it helps to start with the job itself before considering a personality questionnaire. Before comparing providers, employers may wish to identify the requirements of the role and decide which characteristics, if any, would be useful to examine through personality assessment. This means distinguishing between qualities that are genuinely relevant to successful performance and characteristics that simply sound desirable.
For example, imagine a mid-sized company recruiting customer-service employees who must manage complaints and follow unresolved cases through to completion. Conscientiousness may be relevant because the work requires organisation, attention to responsibilities and follow-through. However, a personality score would provide only one perspective on these characteristics. It would not demonstrate whether a candidate can manage a real complaint, record accurate information or identify the next appropriate action.
Other assessment methods can examine these capabilities more directly. A structured interview might explore how the candidate has previously managed competing responsibilities or followed a difficult issue through to resolution. A competency assessment could use a realistic work sample in which the candidate reviews an unresolved customer complaint, documents the outstanding issues and explains the next steps.
These approaches provide different kinds of evidence:
- Personality questionnaires record candidates' descriptions of their typical characteristics and tendencies.
- Structured interviews examine relevant experiences, behaviours and responses to standardised questions.
- Work samples demonstrate how candidates perform tasks resembling those required by the job.
Each method has limitations, and their usefulness depends on how well they are designed and applied. Wood and colleagues also discuss combining personality questionnaires with other selection methods, including interviews, cognitive ability tests and job knowledge assessments. [4]
We encourage employers to select methods that provide relevant evidence about the role, without treating all assessment results as interchangeable.
The weight given to personality scores
A personality questionnaire may contribute useful information to a hiring decision. In our judgement, its influence depends on the strength and relevance of supporting evidence. The modest average relationship between conscientiousness and supervisor-rated performance, together with the limited evidence following actual applicants, supports caution about making personality scores decisive. [3]
The Myers-Briggs Company advises using personality assessment alongside other tools. [2] In our judgement, personality assessment may be useful as one source of information alongside structured interviews, work samples and other job-relevant evidence. We encourage employers to base the weight given to an assessment on its demonstrated validity for the intended decision, without assuming that personality predicts performance.
Employers may wish to examine selection cut-offs particularly carefully when providers recommend them. A cut-off score is a boundary used to classify results. For example, candidates above a specified score might receive a positive recommendation, while those below it might not. Kubiak and colleagues examined personality-based algorithms that used thresholds to generate recommendations. [8]
Before establishing a threshold, it may help to examine the basis for choosing that point on the scale. We encourage employers to ask what evidence supports treating candidates on either side of the boundary differently, including the precision of scores close to it. Two candidates may receive slightly different scores even when the difference is too small, given the measurement uncertainty, to support meaningfully different interpretations. Before introducing a cut-off, employers may wish to clarify how these cases will be handled and who will be responsible for reviewing them.
Questions for a personality assessment provider
Before selecting an assessment, employers may wish to request a sample report and the technical documentation supporting its intended use. It may help to examine how questionnaire responses become trait scores, how those scores are interpreted and what evidence supports any hiring recommendations. Where the provider supplies an overall suitability rating or selection threshold, a useful question is how that result was developed and validated.
Questions to ask before choosing an assessment
- Which traits matter for this role, based on what evidence?
- Does research support prediction for applicants in similar jobs?
- How consistent and precise are the scores?
- Has applicant self-presentation been investigated?
- What evidence supports proposed cut-offs or classifications?
- Were recommendation rates and prediction compared across groups?
- How are available reasonable adjustments managed?
We encourage employers to apply these questions equally to internally developed assessments and externally purchased products.
The Inner View prepares psychometric technical manuals, conducts validation studies and provides statistical interpretation of assessment results. Our services also include test design and related analysis. In our work, we examine how the construct being measured relates to the intended interpretation of scores and the decisions they inform. We also distinguish between conclusions supported by empirical evidence and recommendations based on professional judgement.

Making an informed hiring decision
Personality assessments can contribute information about how candidates describe their characteristics and approach to work. However, their value in recruitment depends on whether that information helps employers make well-founded decisions.
The research reviewed here suggests a modest relationship between conscientiousness and supervisor-rated job performance. It also highlights limitations in evidence from actual applicants and the challenges of interpreting self-reported personality scores when employment is at stake. These findings do not mean personality assessments have no place in recruitment. They point to the distinction between evidence about a questionnaire and support for its intended application.
Before purchasing a questionnaire, it may help to establish which job requirements it addresses, how its scores will be interpreted and what evidence supports the proposed use. Where the assessment contributes to a hiring recommendation, employers may wish to consider its findings alongside other relevant evidence and examine whether it adds useful information to the selection process.
The central question is whether a personality assessment provides dependable, job-relevant information that improves the decision you need to make.
We encourage employers to use that question to guide the choice of instrument, its place in recruitment and the weight assigned to results.
Personality profile assessment
Explore The Inner View's personality assessment services, including personality profiles and the interpretation of psychological assessment results for workplace decisions.
The Inner View
Get new writing in your inbox
Join the mailing list for research, ideas, and perspectives on psychology, human behaviour, and professional development.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most reliable personality assessments for hiring?
Does Talogy market the 16pf for hiring?
Can a candidate fail a personality assessment?
Is it legal to use personality tests in hiring?
Which platforms offer pre-employment psychometric testing?
References
- [1]The Myers-Briggs Company. (n.d.). Addressing the inaccuracies in 'Persona' about the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) assessment. Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://www.themyersbriggs.com/en-us/access-resources/articles/addressing-the-inaccuracies-in-persona
- [2]The Myers-Briggs Company. (n.d.). Should personality assessments be used in hiring? Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://au.themyersbriggs.com/themyersbriggs-blog-should-personality-assessments-be-used-in-hiring.aspx
- [3]Watrin, L., Weihrauch, L., & Wilhelm, O. (2023). The criterion-related validity of conscientiousness in personnel selection: A meta-analytic reality check. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 31(2), 286-301. https://doi.org/10.1111/ijsa.12413 Author preprint: https://osf.io/xzw7c
- [4]Wood, J. K., Anglim, J., & Horwood, S. (2024). Less evaluative measures of personality in job applicant contexts: The effect on socially desirable responding and criterion validity. Journal of Personality Assessment, 106(2), 245-260. https://doi.org/10.1080/00223891.2023.2251158
- [5]Talogy. (n.d.). 16pf personality assessment. Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://talogy.com/en/talent-management-solutions/assessments/16pf-personality-assessment/
- [6]SHL. (n.d.). SHL Occupational Personality Questionnaire (OPQ). Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://www.shl.com/products/assessments/personality-assessment/shl-occupational-personality-questionnaire-opq/
- [7]Criteria Corp. (n.d.). Personality tests. Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://www.criteriacorp.com/assessments/personality-tests
- [8]Kubiak, E., Efremova, M. I., Baron, S., & Frasca, K. J. (2023). Gender equity in hiring: Examining the effectiveness of a personality-based algorithm. Frontiers in Psychology, 14, 1219865. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1219865
- [9]U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (n.d.). Employment tests and selection procedures. Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/employment-tests-and-selection-procedures
- [10]GOV.UK. (n.d.). Employers: preventing discrimination. Recruitment. Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://www.gov.uk/employer-preventing-discrimination/recruitment
- [11]British Psychological Society. (n.d.). Psychological Testing Centre. Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://ptc.bps.org.uk/

